Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co.

is located at 901 High St., Worthington, Ohio 43085 (across from the brand new CVS Pharmacy Building, diaginally across from the Dairy Queen, and about a block and a half north of Rt. 161).

Our retail shop is open:

Monday thru Friday-- 9 am to 6 pm
Saturday-- 9 am to 5 pm
Sunday-- Closed
____________________________________________________

Product Menu

COOKIES

Regular $1.00/ea. $11.50/doz.

# Oatmeal Choc. Chip
# Chocolate Chip
# Oatmeal Raisin
# Oatmeal Raisin Walnut
# Choc.-White Choc.-Pecan
# Sugar Cookies
# Brown Sugar Walnut
# Peanut Butter
# Peanut Butter Choc. Chip
# Oatmeal Butterscotch

# Regular ButterCream-Iced Cut-Outs--$1.50/ea. $16.70/doz.
# Special Seasonally/Holiday decorated Cut-out Cookies--$1.75 ea. $21.00/doz.
# Pumpkin Spice--$1.75/ea. $21.00/doz.
# Gingerbread men/women--$1.75 each. $21.00/doz.

# Cross Cutout Cookies--$1.20 each. $14.40/doz.

Thumbprint Cookies (Raspberry, Cream Cheese, or Lemon Curd fillings to choose from) $1.25 ea.
*
Peanut Butter Blossoms w/Choc. Kiss $1.25 ea.
*
Other new items as priced at the showcase.

 

Dessert-Breads

Pumpkin Bread, Banana Bread, and Almond Poppy-Seed Bread, topped with a confectioner's glaze.

$12.95 for large, and $6.95 for Small.

 

SCONES

$2.25/ea. $24.00/doz.

# Blueberry
# Raspberry
# Orange
# Cranberry-Orange
# Chocolate-Chip
# White-Choc.-Pecan
# Cream
# White-Choc.-Apricot

* Cherry-Almond

* Peaches & Cream

* Pumpkin 

# Cin.-Bun Scones

 

BARS

$2.25/ea. $24.60/doz.
# Raspberry Bars
# Texas Pecan Pie Bars
# Chocolate Pecan Pie Bars
# Coconut Lime Sours Bars


FRUIT PIES

(W)hole (S)mall

# Cherry $14.95/Whole $5.95/Sm.
# Apple $14.95/W $5.95/S
# Blackberry $14.95/W $5.95/S
# Peach $14.95/W $5.95/S
# Strawberry-Rhubarb $14.95/W $5.95/S
# Very Berry $14.95/W $5.95/S
# Pumpkin $14.95/W $5.95/S
# Sugar-Free Apple $15.95/W
# Pecan Pie $16.95/W

#White-Chocolate Pecan  $18.95/W

Nantucket Cranberry/Walnut Pie $18.95

Actually not a pie, but a scrumptious mixture of Cranberries & Walnuts, over a chewy Shortbread type crust!

It was chosen by customers, two Thanksgivings ago, as the most popular new delicious product.

* Cherry & Apple Pies are available in Traditional Double Crust, or Crumb Tops.

CREAM PIES

(L)arge (S)mall
$12.95/L $5.95/Sm.
# Peanut Butter " " "
# Chocolate-Peanut Butter " " "
# Coconut " " "
# Banana " " "
# Chocolate

# Key Lime $15.95/L, $6.45/Sm.

# French Silk $15.95/L, $6.45/Sm.

 

CUPCAKES

# Vanilla w/ vanilla buttercream icing (BC) $2.35

# Chocolate w/ Van. BC, Cappucino BC, or Chocolate BC icing $2.35

# Vanilla or Chocolate with Raspberry Filling $2.60.

# Carrot Cake w/ Cream-Cheese Icing $2.75
# Strawberry w/ Strawberry BC $2.75
# Key Lime w/ Vanilla BC icing $2.75
# Italian Cream (made with coconut & pecans) w/ Van. BC icing, topped with coconut & Pecans $2.75

# Buckeye Cupcakes--Choc. Cupcakes W/Peanut-Butter Icing $2.75

# Spice Cupcakes or Pumpkin Cupcakes w/ Maple icing $2.75

CANDLES

# Sparkler Candles $2.50
# Neon Candles $2.00
# Swirl Candles $3.00
# Glitter Candles $1.95

 

CAKES

Order of cake pricing-grid information below is:


Size--Un-Decorated.--Standard Decoration--Fillings--Colored Frosting--Colored- Boarder.

To give some examples, looking at the price grid below:

# A 6" Chocolate or Vanilla cake with your choice of frosting, with a un-decorated would cost $19.95.

# If you wanted the 6" Choc. or Van cake with a standard decoration (such as piped colored icing decorations in the form of Swiss Dots, fireworks, swirls, flowers...see occasion cake page), the price would then be $23.95.

# If you also wanted to include a Raspberry or Lemon Filling between the cake layers of your 6" Choc. or Van cake, it would cost an additional $3.00.

# If you would like to have a specially colored boarder at the base of your 6" cake, it would cost you an additional .50.

The additional costs for any of these items, will change depending on the size of cake, as shown on the cake grid below.

 

Vanillia and Chocolate Cakes

 Size * Un-decor. * Standard decor. * Spec.Filling * Color Icing * C. Border

# 6"   $19.95      *         $23.95            *      $3.00     *     $2.50    *        .50

# 8"   $27.95      *         $33.95            *      $4.50     *     $3.75    *     $1.25

# 10" $36.95      *         $45.95            *      $7.00     *     $5.00    *     $2.00

# 12" $47.95      *         $62.95            *      $9.00     *     $6.50    *     $3.00

# 14" $68.95      *         $87.95            *      $10.50     *   $7.50    *     $4.00

# 16" $88.95      *         $115.95          *      $12.50    *     $8.50    *     $5.25

# 18" $115.95    *         $149.95          *      $14.50    *     $9.50    *     $6.50

# 20" $142.95    *         $182.95          *      $17.50    *     $11.00  *     $7.75

# 1/4 sheet $28.95       $35.95            *         NA      *     $3.75    *     $2.50

# 1/2 sheet $49.95       $64.95            *         NA      *     $6.50    *     $4.00

# Full sheet $98.95      $119.95           *         NA     *      $8.50   *     $5.50

 

Italian Cream, CarrotCake, Keylime, Strawberry Cakes

  Size * Un-decorated * Standard Decoration           Same as Above.

# 6"            $23.95     *         $27.95                

# 8"            $33.95     *         $39.95                     

# 10"          $43.95     *         $53.95

# 12"          $61.95     *         $78.95

# 14"          $80.95     *         $99.95

# 16"          $104.95   *         $125.95

# 18"          $134.95   *         $153.95 

# 20"          $162.95   *         $194.95

# 1/4 sheet $33.95     *         $40.95

# 1/2 sheet $59.95     *         $74.95

# Full sheet $115.95   *        $132.95

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

# Double-layer 1/4 Sheet Cake in Chocolate, Vanilla, or half & half,

un-decorated-$57.90, Standard decoration-$71.90.

If Other Cake Flavors, un-decorated-$67.90, Standard decoration-$81.90.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 # Double-layer 1/2 Sheet Cake in Chocolate, Vanilla, or half & half,

un-decorated-$99.90, Standard decoration-$129.90

Other Cake Flavors, un-decorated-$119.90, Standard decoration-$149.90.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 # Double-Layer Full-Sheet Cake in Chocolate, Vanilla, or half & half,

Un-decorated-$197.90,  Standard decoration-$239.90

Other Cake Flavors, un-decorated-$231.90,  Standard decoration-$265.90

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Servings Guide

Approximate number of cake slices/servings per size:

 6" in diameter, 5" tall, two-layer iced cake, will provide between 6 to 9 slices.

8".........12-16 slices.

10".......20-30.

12"......30-40.

14".....45-60.

16".....55-75.

18".....75-100.

20".....100-125 slices.

1/4 Sheet cake.....24--(2"x 2") slices.

1/2 Sheet cake.....48--(2"x 2") slices.

Full Sheet cake.....96--(2"x 2") slices

 

# Smash Cake (baby's first birthday)-Vanilla or Chocolate 6' single layer cake w/decoration $12.95. For cake flavors below, smash cake is $14.50. (all standard decoration. An extra fee would be charged if special decoration is ordered).

# German Chocolate Cake- 9" only... $33.95 * covered with traditional German Chocolate coconut & pecan icing.  Normally never decorated, except the occasional free writing, but, If decorated with colored buttercream icing--$39.95.

# Boston Cream Pie- 8" only... $19.95

# Pineapple & Mandarin Orange Upside-Down Cakes- 6" ...$20.95 // 10" ...$28.95.

# Plain New York Style CheeseCake...9"-- $24.95.  If with topping--$28.95.

 

Icings/Frostings

Most cakes include a generous covering of our famous Buttercream Icing.
You may request the icing flavor of your choice, with the cake of your dreams, but the following combinations are the norm:


# Vanilla ButtercreamIcing/Frosting covers Vanilla, Chocolate, Italian Cream, and Keylime cakes.
# Chocolate Buttercream Icing covers Chocolate cakes.
# Strawberry Buttercream Icing covers Strawberry Cakes.
# Cream Cheese Icing cover Carrot Cakes. Vanilla Buttercream Icing also goes well with Carrot Cakes.

# Peanut Butter Buttercream Icing is normally available by request.
# Pure Maple Buttercream Icing is normally available during the Thanksgiving through Christmas seasons, to cover the seasonal Pumpkin Cakes.

# Whipped Topping as Icing.

 

__

Ball-Cake Prices:

(Normal Sports decorated cakes, not in the form of a ball, are priced as normal)

 * Baseball, Basketball, Golf Ball, or Tennis Ball(6-8 servings)....$26.95.

Special fillings (Raspberry or Lemon Curd)...$2.50 additional.

* Football(8-10 servings)....$29.95

Special fillings(" ")....$3.25 additional.

* Soccer Ball(6-8 servings)....$30.95.

Special fillings(" ")....$2.50 additional.

* See menu page for pricing for the regular cylindric and sheet cake prices.

___________________________________________

BEVERAGES


Bottled Water $1.40
Coffee $0.95/sm. $1.15/lg.
Milk $0.95/sm. $1.20/lg.
Fruit Juice $1.25/sm. $1.75/lg.
Soda $1.00

Store Hours:

Monday thru Friday-- 9 am to 6 pm
Saturday-- 9 am to 5 pm
Sunday-- Closed 

Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co.
901 N. High Street, Worthington, Ohio 43085 
Phone: 614-888-7437
Fax: 614-433-7437
Email Address: mrs.goodmans@gmail.com